Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Selling a longtime home can unlock substantial equity, reduce maintenance responsibilities and open the door to a new lifestyle. But downsizing isn’t always as straightforward as moving into a smaller house. Homeowners must weigh the cost of purchasing another property, the convenience of a new location, the emotional impact of leaving their neighborhood and the practical challenge of sorting through years of belongings.
On Atlanta Real Estate Forum Radio, Frank Golley, broker with Golley Realty Group, joined host Carol Morgan to explore what homeowners should consider before downsizing or right-sizing their homes. His advice highlights an important distinction: The goal isn’t necessarily to buy less house. It’s to find a home that better fits the next stage of life.
What Is the Difference Between Downsizing and Right-Sizing?
Downsizing generally means moving into a smaller home, while right-sizing means choosing a property that better supports a homeowner’s current needs, priorities and budget. The two can overlap, but a successful move doesn’t always require fewer bedrooms or less square footage.
“Most people buy the same basic size house that they’ve got,” Golley said.
A household might still need three bedrooms for visiting family or a home office. The change could instead involve moving from a two-story house to a single-level home, trading a large yard for a low-maintenance property or choosing a condominium with shared amenities.
The key is to evaluate how a home functions rather than focusing exclusively on its size. A smaller property may reduce upkeep, but a better layout, a more convenient location or fewer maintenance responsibilities could matter more than square footage alone.
Why Do Homeowners Decide to Downsize?
Downsizing often becomes appealing when a homeowner’s circumstances change. Retirement, health considerations, the loss of a spouse, children leaving home or a desire to live closer to family can all prompt a reassessment of housing needs.
For some, the priority is avoiding stairs or eliminating the responsibilities that come with maintaining a large property. Others want to access the equity tied up in their homes, simplify daily life or move closer to restaurants, shopping, health care and social activities.
Family can be another major consideration. Moving closer to adult children and grandchildren may seem like an obvious next step, but it’s important to consider what daily life will look like after the move. Family members have their own work schedules, commitments and routines, and living nearby does not necessarily mean spending more time together.
Before listing a home, homeowners should identify what they hope to gain. A move driven by a specific, achievable goal is more likely to deliver lasting benefits than one based on a general feeling that it is time for a change.
Does Downsizing Actually Save Money?
Selling a large home and buying a smaller one can appear to be a straightforward way to lower housing costs. In practice, the financial benefits depend on the property’s value, the cost of the replacement home, financing needs and the expenses associated with moving.
“I think a lot of people think they’re going to save a lot more money than they really do,” Golley said.
Property taxes, insurance, utilities, maintenance and homeowners association fees can all affect the bottom line. A condominium may eliminate some exterior maintenance responsibilities, for example, but monthly association dues can offset part of those savings. Transaction costs, moving expenses and repairs or updates to the new home also need to be considered.
What Costs Should Homeowners Compare Before Moving?
A realistic comparison should account for the full cost of staying versus moving. Homeowners can start by estimating:
- Current housing costs: Mortgage payments, property taxes, insurance, utilities, maintenance and ongoing repairs.
- Replacement housing costs: Purchase price, mortgage payments, taxes, insurance, association fees and expected maintenance.
- One-time moving expenses: Real estate commissions and other transaction costs, moving services, storage, renovations and furnishings.
- Lifestyle expenses: Transportation, access to health care, proximity to family and the cost of amenities or services.
The equity from selling a home can provide financial flexibility, but it does not automatically translate into lower monthly expenses. Comparing the full cost of each option can help homeowners determine whether moving will meaningfully improve their financial position.
How Can Capital Gains Taxes Affect a Downsizing Decision?
Selling a home for substantially more than its purchase price can also have tax implications. Eligible homeowners may qualify to exclude up to $250,000 in capital gains from the sale of a primary residence, or up to $500,000 for qualifying married couples filing jointly. Eligibility depends on IRS ownership, use and other requirements.
Because individual circumstances vary, homeowners should consult a qualified tax professional before making a decision based on the expected proceeds from a sale.
How Do Mortgage Rates Affect the Decision to Downsize?
Mortgage rates can make downsizing less financially attractive, particularly for homeowners who secured a low interest rate several years ago and would need to finance their next home.
A lower purchase price does not necessarily mean a lower mortgage payment. The interest rate, loan term, down payment and amount borrowed all affect the monthly cost.
During the episode, Golley illustrated this challenge by comparing a $500,000 mortgage at 3% interest with a $335,000 mortgage at 6.5%. Assuming 30-year fixed-rate loans, the principal and interest payments are approximately comparable. The example shows why buyers should evaluate financing costs alongside purchase prices.
For homeowners with a paid-off property or a low-rate mortgage, staying may be financially advantageous. Selling could still make sense for lifestyle or accessibility reasons, but the decision should account for the cost of giving up favorable financing and purchasing another home.
What Types of Homes Are Best for Downsizers in Metro Atlanta?
The right property depends on how homeowners want to live, what they can afford and which responsibilities they want to leave behind. In Metro Atlanta, options range from smaller single-family homes and townhomes to condominiums in walkable communities.
A single-level home may appeal to someone who wants to avoid stairs without giving up a yard or private outdoor space. Townhomes can offer less exterior maintenance than detached houses, while condominiums may provide shared amenities and convenient access to nearby businesses.
The challenge is finding a property that meets several priorities at once. Someone who wants multiple bedrooms, walkability and a central location may discover that the available homes cost more than expected. In some areas, a condominium may be the more practical option for staying close to preferred destinations.
Homeowners should identify their nonnegotiables early. These might include a first-floor primary bedroom, space for guests, an elevator, outdoor access or a particular monthly budget. Knowing which features matter most can make the search more productive.
Why Are Location and Walkability So Important to Downsizers?
Right-sizing is as much about where you live as the home itself. A smaller property in a convenient location can make daily life easier, especially for those who want to drive less or spend more time in their community.
Walkability can provide access to restaurants, shops, parks and social activities without requiring a car for every outing. Proximity to health care may also become increasingly important as homeowners consider their long-term needs.
Metro Atlanta offers a range of lifestyle options, but each comes with trade-offs. Decatur, for example, offers an established, walkable environment, although housing costs can make it challenging for buyers seeking a smaller home at a lower price. Other communities may provide more single-family options but require greater reliance on driving.
The appeal of a destination should also be weighed against practical considerations. A quiet mountain setting or a move to a college town may sound attractive, but access to hospitals, transportation, family and everyday services can influence whether the location remains a good fit over time.
How Should Buyers Evaluate a Location for Retirement?
Rather than choosing a location based on a vacation, a short visit or an idealized vision of retirement, homeowners should consider what ordinary life will look like there.
Questions to ask include:
- Are grocery stores, health care providers and other essential services nearby?
- Can you walk to restaurants, parks or community activities?
- How long will it take to reach family and friends?
- Will the location still work if driving becomes more difficult?
- Does the area offer housing options that fit your budget and future needs?
The goal is to find a place that supports everyday routines, not just one that looks appealing on paper.
What Is the Most Emotional Part of Downsizing?
A home can hold decades of memories, making the decision to leave more complicated than a financial calculation. Furniture, photographs, collections and family heirlooms may represent important milestones or relationships. Letting go of those belongings can feel like letting go of part of a person’s history.
When Should Homeowners Start Planning a Downsizing Move?
Downsizing often takes longer than expected because the process involves more than selling one home and buying another. Homeowners may need to research neighborhoods, compare housing costs, organize belongings, prepare a property for sale and coordinate two transactions.
Some retirement communities, including continuing care retirement communities, may have waiting lists that extend well beyond a year. Waiting until a move becomes urgent can limit the available choices and create unnecessary pressure.
There is no single timeline that works for every household. A move to an available condominium may be relatively straightforward, while a transition to a retirement community with a waiting list may require years of preparation. The timeline should reflect the complexity of the move, the condition of the current home, the availability of suitable replacement properties and the amount of belongings that need to be sorted.
A practical first step is to establish a realistic budget based on the estimated value of the current home and the costs of a replacement property. From there, homeowners can identify suitable communities, determine which home features are essential and begin decluttering well before the listing date.
Starting early also creates room to reconsider the plan if the financial or lifestyle benefits are not as strong as expected.
When Is Downsizing the Wrong Decision?
Downsizing is not always the best choice, particularly when the decision is driven by a temporary frustration or an unrealistic picture of life somewhere else.
A homeowner who is tired of yardwork, for example, may assume that moving to a condominium will solve every maintenance concern. But association fees, building rules, limited storage or a less convenient location could introduce new challenges. Likewise, moving closer to family may not deliver the expected lifestyle if relatives have limited time to spend together.
Before committing, homeowners should distinguish between the problems they want to solve and the changes they hope a new home will create. Some concerns may be addressed by modifying the current property, hiring help for maintenance or reconfiguring living spaces.
For those considering a move to a new city or community, a temporary stay can provide useful perspective.
“Go rent something. Go test it out. Go live there temporarily,” Golley advised.
Renting before buying allows homeowners to experience the neighborhood, daily routines and practical realities without making an immediate long-term commitment. It can reveal whether the location truly meets their needs or whether the appeal was based primarily on expectations.
Does Metro Atlanta Have Enough Housing Options for Downsizers?
Finding the right home can be challenging when downsizers want a combination of affordability, accessibility, multiple bedrooms and a convenient location. The available options vary considerably by neighborhood, and the most desirable features do not always come together at a price that fits the buyer’s budget.
In a walkable, established community, buyers may need to consider a condominium to stay within their budget. In other areas, including parts of Roswell, they may find more single-family homes that meet their space requirements. Each option comes with different trade-offs involving price, maintenance, transportation and access to services.
Flexibility is important. Homeowners who focus on a single property type or neighborhood may overlook alternatives that better meet their overall goals. At the same time, compromising on essential needs, such as accessibility or proximity to health care, can create problems later.
A clear list of priorities can help buyers evaluate the available inventory realistically and determine where they are willing to compromise.
What Questions Should Homeowners Ask Before Downsizing?
Before listing a home or beginning a search, homeowners should answer three fundamental questions:
- Why do you want to move? Identify the primary motivation, whether it is reducing maintenance, accessing equity, improving accessibility, relocating closer to family or changing lifestyles.
- What do you want to change? Define the specific features of the current home or location that no longer work. This may include stairs, yard maintenance, distance from amenities or the cost of maintaining unused space.
- When do you need to make the move? Consider whether the transition is optional or tied to a specific event, such as retirement, a health concern or a move to a community with limited availability.
These answers help establish whether downsizing is the right solution and what the next home needs to provide. They also create a framework for evaluating properties, comparing costs and avoiding decisions based on short-term emotions.
How Can Homeowners Prepare for a Successful Downsizing Move?
A successful transition begins with planning the next stage of life before putting the current home on the market. Homeowners can use these steps to make the process more manageable.
- Assess the current home. Estimate its market value and review the costs of maintaining it.
- Set a realistic budget. Include the replacement property’s purchase price, financing, taxes, insurance, fees and moving expenses.
- Define the next home’s priorities. Determine the required bedroom count, accessibility features, location and level of maintenance.
- Research communities and property types. Compare single-family homes, townhomes, condominiums and retirement communities based on lifestyle and affordability.
- Begin decluttering early. Sort belongings over time and avoid paying to store items that may not fit the next home.
- Evaluate the long-term picture. Consider how the property and location will serve changing mobility, health care and transportation needs.
- Test unfamiliar locations. If possible, rent before buying in a new community to see whether it works for everyday life.
The process should be guided by the homeowner’s goals rather than an assumption that a smaller property is automatically better. The right move is one that improves daily life while remaining financially sustainable.
How Can Golley Realty Group Help Homeowners Plan Their Next Move?
Golley Realty Group is a boutique real estate firm that began by focusing on Decatur and has since expanded to serve a broader range of communities. Homebuyers can explore the company’s resources, including its downsizing guide, to begin comparing communities, identifying housing options and clarifying priorities before starting a search.
Is Downsizing the Right Move for You?
Downsizing in Atlanta is not simply a matter of exchanging a large home for a smaller one. The decision involves evaluating housing costs, mortgage rates, location, accessibility, personal belongings and the kind of lifestyle a homeowner wants in the years ahead.
For some, a condominium or smaller home may provide the right combination of convenience and reduced maintenance. Others may discover that keeping their current property is the more practical choice, especially if they have a low mortgage rate or can address their concerns without moving.
The most important step is to define what the move is meant to accomplish. With a clear set of priorities, a realistic budget and enough time to explore the options, homeowners can make a decision that fits their needs rather than simply choosing a smaller house.
For more conversations about the people, trends and decisions shaping the real estate industry, listen to Atlanta Real Estate Forum Radio and explore the latest episodes at Atlanta Real Estate Forum.
Podcast Thanks
Thank you to Denim Marketing for sponsoring Atlanta Real Estate Forum Radio. Known as a trendsetter, Denim Marketing has been blogging since 2006 and podcasting since 2011. Contact them when you need quality, original content for social media, public relations, blogging, email marketing and promotions. A comfortable fit for companies of all shapes and sizes, Denim Marketing understands marketing strategies are not one-size-fits-all. The agency works with your company to create a perfectly tailored marketing strategy that will suit your needs and niche. Try Denim Marketing on for size by calling 770-383-3360 or by visiting www.DenimMarketing.com.
About Atlanta Real Estate Forum Radio
Atlanta Real Estate Forum Radio, presented by Denim Marketing, highlights the movers and shakers in the Atlanta real estate industry – the home builders, developers, Realtors and suppliers working to provide the American dream for Atlantans. For more information on how you can be featured as a guest, contact Denim Marketing at 770-383-3360 or fill out the Atlanta Real Estate Forum contact form. Subscribe to the Atlanta Real Estate Forum Radio podcast on iTunes, and if you like this week’s show, be sure to rate it. Atlanta Real Estate Forum Radio was recently honored on FeedSpot’s Top 100 Atlanta Podcasts, ranking 11th overall and number one out of all ranked real estate podcasts.
